We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The best pillow for side and back sleepers has to do something most pillows don’t: work at two different heights in the same night. On your side, the pillow fills the space between your head and the mattress, past your shoulder. On your back, that shoulder gap is gone and your head needs less lift. This guide shows you how to handle that, with three pillow types that each solve it a different way.
Quick answer: look for a pillow you can adjust (removable fill) or a shape with a lower center and higher sides. Then check the height in both positions during the first nights, and read the return policy before you buy.
Why combination sleepers struggle with one pillow
The Sleep Foundation groups pillows by height: low loft is under 3 inches, medium is 3 to 5 inches, and high is over 5 inches. It says side sleepers generally prefer a high-loft pillow (Sleep Foundation).
Our rule of thumb, based on how the body and pillow fit together: when you roll onto your back, your shoulder no longer holds your head up, so a pillow tall enough for side sleeping can push your chin toward your chest. A pillow low enough for your back can let your head drop when you turn on your side. That is the loft dilemma, and it’s why many people who switch positions feel no single pillow is right.
You’re not alone. In comments under popular pillow videos, one viewer wrote: “Most people who side-sleep also roll onto their backs.” Another said they sleep “on back and sides. not a fan of firm pillows but need some height.”
If you sleep only on your side, our main best pillow for side sleepers guide is the better starting point.
Three ways to get two heights from one pillow
| Type | Example | How it handles side + back | Feel | Returns (per the maker) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adjustable fill | Layla Kapok Pillow | You remove fill to find a middle height | Soft, moldable | 30-night trial, free returns |
| Contour sold in sizes | Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Neck | One fixed contour, chosen by shoulder size | Firm | Pillows may not be returned |
| Butterfly shape | Melara Max | Side wings; loft not published | Memory foam | 30 days from delivery; buyer pays return shipping |
We don’t quote prices because they change often.
How each type handles two heights
- Adjustable fill (Layla Kapok): a moldable fill lets you push more material under your neck when you’re on your side and flatten it a little when you’re on your back. Good if you don’t know your ideal height yet.
- Contour sold in sizes (TEMPUR-Neck): one fixed contour has to work in both positions, so Tempur-Pedic’s advice to pick the smaller size when you fall between two matters even more for combination sleepers. Firm, and not returnable according to the maker. Our guide on how to use a contour pillow covers the high side and the low side.
- Butterfly shape (Melara Max): a lower center for the back and raised sides for side sleeping, plus room for the arms. The loft isn’t published, so check your head position on your back and on your side during the first nights. See our butterfly pillow guide and the Melara Max review.
Full specifications and sources for all three are in our main best pillow for side sleepers guide.
How to choose the best pillow for side and back sleepers
- Find your side-sleeping height first. Measure your shoulder with our pillow loft guide. That’s the tallest height you’ll need.
- Ask which position you spend most time in. If it’s mostly back, lean toward the lower end; if it’s mostly side, lean higher and look for a lower center for your back.
- Think about your mattress. Our rule of thumb: on a soft mattress your shoulder sinks, so you may need a little less loft on your side; on a firm one, a little more.
- Prefer adjustable or two-height shapes over a single flat height.
- Check the return terms. Trial length, who pays return shipping, and whether pillows can be returned at all vary a lot between brands.
Test it in both positions
During the first nights, lie on your back and on your side and ask someone to take a photo from the side and from behind. On your back, your chin shouldn’t be pushed toward your chest. On your side, your head should look level with your spine, not tilted up or down. Our guide on how to use a pillow as a side sleeper covers shoulder and arm placement.
When a pillow isn’t the answer
A pillow is a comfort product, not a treatment. If you wake up sore, check height and position first; our guide to pillows for side sleepers with neck and shoulder pain explains what to look at. If neck pain keeps coming back, talk to a doctor or physical therapist. The Sleep Foundation advises seeing a provider promptly if neck pain comes with fever, headache, weakness or shortness of breath (Sleep Foundation). If snoring is your concern, read pillows and snoring first.
How we put this guide together
We used each manufacturer’s published information (fill, sizes, firmness, trial, warranty and returns), the Sleep Foundation’s loft and sleep-position guidance, our household use of the Melara Max, and questions raised in comments under popular pillow videos. We did not lab-test these pillows. Read how we review pillows.
Also read our full review:
Melara Max Pillow Review 2026: Who This Butterfly Pillow Fits (and Who It Doesn't)
Affiliate disclosure
This content contains affiliate links. If you buy through one of these links, we may earn a commission from the company selling the product, at no extra cost to you. This commercial relationship never influences our editorial review — see our methodology.
Also read our health disclaimer and the full affiliate disclosure page.